Complaints about forced hot air usually stem from uncomfortable temperature swings or dryness.

Large temperature swings can happen for several reasons:

1)   Oversized heating systems
In the past, it has been common practice to install heating systems that are 2 to 3 times too large. These systems send out a blast of very hot air over a short period of time and then shut off when the thermostat detects that the desired temperature has been reached.  A appropriate sized system that runs for a longer period of time provides a more even and comfortable distribution of heat. The photo below is a perfect example. We found this  15 ton boiler in a 6 ton house.
2)   Location of the thermostat
Thermostats in rooms heated by the sun may cause the rest of the house to be cold.  Alternately, a thermostat that is located in a room that tends to be cooler may cause heat to come on in other rooms that are already warm.  Thermostats should be located in spaces where comfort is a priority.  An experienced HVAC installer will be able to choose a thermostat location for optimum performance and comfort. Many comfort issues can be resolved by moving the thermostat to a more appropriate location.

Combustion based forced air heating systems are drying because the hot humid exhaust air is vented outside with dry cold air coming in to replace it.  Because geothermal systems do not have exhaust or fresh air make-up, this exchange of hot humid air for dry cold air does not happen.

 

 

No matter which type of heating system you have, humidity can always be added during the winter months. We have seen the following techniques:

  • Stand alone or central humidifier
  • Boiling a pot of water on the stove
  • Vent a clothes dryer into the room rather than outside
  • Run a hot shower with the bathroom door open and the ventilation fan turned off

Homeowners Bill and Joyce in Leominster, MA were tired of fuel oil prices and were ready for a greener solution to home heating and cooling. Joyce contacted EnergySmart in September when their air conditioning system quit working. Within a few days of her call we visited their home to assess the property for geothermal.

We found their home to be an ideal candidate for geothermal because:

  • The house had pre-existing ductwork;
  • The house was heated with fuel oil (see photo on right);
  • The air conditioning needed to be replaced;
  • The front yard had plenty of space for drilling;
  • The walk-out basement made equipment delivery very convenient;
  • The homeowners are eligible for the 30% Federal Tax Credit for geothermal installations; and
  • Residents of Leominster are eligible for 0% interest loans through the Mass Save Heat Loan program.

Drilling consisted of two 6-inch diameter borings with a depth of 250 feet each. Pipes were installed into each of the borings and sealed in place with geothermal grout. The pipes were brought into the house through 2.5-inch cores through the concrete foundation approximately 4-feet below grade and were connected to the geothermal heat pump.

The existing oil furnace, oil tank, and air conditioning condenser were removed as the unit will provide both heating and cooling. The geothermal unit was placed in the location of the old oil furnace. Although the homeowners have a new propane fueled on-demand water heater, a desuperheater was included with the geothermal unit should they decide to utilize the hot-water assist feature in the future. A new programmable EnergyStar heat pump thermostat with LED display replaced their old thermostat.  We also provided a power meter that will monitor electricity use by the geothermal heat pump in real-time.

Some benefits of converting to geothermal:

  • Same piece of equipment provides heating and cooling (see photo on right);
  • Hot water-assist feature can be activated in the future;
  • Re-usable electrostatic air filter improves air quality and decreases waste;
  • Oil tank is removed thus improving indoor air quality;
  • No combustion for heating thus eliminating carbon monoxide risk;
  • Highly efficient heating and cooling; and
  • Adjustable fan speed allows for superior dehumidification in the summer

Client Testimonial:

“Looking forward to not having to purchase oil any longer!”

“Couldn’t be happier with the installation or all of you at EnergySmart Alternatives!”

If you would like to see more photos of this installation, please visit our YouTube Channel or visit our online photo album!

In this post, I thought I would address a common misconception about geothermal that has been brought up several times over the past few months. The recurring comment that I have heard goes something like this: “I heard that you can drill and drill and not reach what you need. Then you wasted all that money and you still need to install a gas or oil furnace because geothermal won’t work.”

I have installed over 200 tons of geothermal heating systems throughout New England and there has never been a situation where we haven’t “reached what we needed”. First, it starts with an understanding of how the underground components of a geothermal systems actually work.

Closed Loop Systems

Closed loop systems (antifreeze circulated through underground pipes) in New England are usually installed in 6″ vertical borings ranging from 250 to 400 feet in depth. The borehole is drilled right through bedrock which is usually encountered within 0 to 50 feet. Groundwater is typically encountered within this same depth range.  During the heating season, these systems depend on heat being transferred from the bedrock and groundwater, through the pipe into the antifreeze, and then into the geothermal heat pump in the house.  While groundwater improves the heat transfer properties of the underground portions of the geothermal system, the presence of copious amounts of groundwater is not absolutely critical to the operation of the system.

Open Loop Systems

Open loop systems circulate actual well water through the geothermal heat pump system.  In some cases, the well doesn’t have enough capacity to support a geothermal system.  This problem can be overcome by frac-ing the well or deepening the well to increase its capacity and yield.  In extreme cases, systems that were originally intended to be open loop can be converted to closed loop when the well doesn’t produce enough water.

Sometimes, salty or brackish water can be encountered when drilling in close proximity to the ocean.  Poor quality water can wreak havoc on geothermal system components causing corrosion and mineral deposits.  Similarly, if salt water or hard water is encountered, systems originally intended to be open loop can be converted to closed loop.

I hope this post clarifies that there is almost never a situation where you can drill and drill and not be able to install a geothermal system.  Usually, the problem is whether or not the drill rig fits on the property!

 

Recently, I met with a local architectural designer for lunch and we were discussing how one might go about decreasing their carbon footprint.  Most people would think solar panels, right? When we looked at the numbers, geothermal was the winner  by a landslide.

Suppose we take a typical home in New England that has oil heat – say 2,500 square feet of conditioned space. Let’s compare the carbon footprint reduction associated with solar PV panels and a geothermal heat pump system.  We used the US EPA Household Carbon Footprint Calculator as the basis for our back-of-the-envelope calculations.

It is likely that the home would use about 1,000 gallons of home heating oil each year which is equivalent to 22,300 lbs of carbon dioxide.  The geothermal system would use about 8,000 kWh of electricity which is equivalent to 6,700 lbs of carbon dioxide.  The net reduction would be 15,600 lbs of carbon dioxide (~70% reduction) just for heating alone.

Solar PV panels are simply replacing one source of electricity for another.  This ‘typical’ home could possibly install a 8 kW system which is roughly equivalent to producing 6,600 kWh of electricity each year.  The PV system therefore results in a net reduction of 5,500 lbs of carbon dioxide.

Clearly, eliminating fuel oil has a much larger impact on your carbon footprint that offsetting your electricity use with solar panels.  Of course, using solar panels to offset your geothermal electricity use would be the ultimate green combination!

If you would like to calculate your own carbon footprint, try out the US EPA Household Carbon Footprint Calculator. Let us know how your home rates!

As someone who makes a living designing and installing geothermal systems in New England, I cannot tell you how disheartening it is to hear and read all the misinformation about how goethermal works, or whether it works at all. Let’s face it – there’s a lot of bad information our there. I’ve heard it all. Today, I’d like to share with you two of the most popular myths about geothermal heating and cooling systems.

Myth #1: You need to buy a fossil fuel heating system anyway to serve as a backup.

This simply isn’t true. A properly designed geothermal system will provide all of the heating and cooling that you need. There is no need whatsoever to install a gas or oil boiler as backup.

Myth #2: You can’t install these systems in the winter.

The drill rig that installs geothermal borings drills right through bedrock. They certainly have enough power to drill through ice.

Trenching in winter can be quite difficult, though; the degree of difficulty depends on your geographic location and ground cover conditions.  A few straw bails can keep the frost out of the ground long enough to trench within a small area. Even if frost penetrates through the straw, the ground usually isn’t frozen for more than a few inches.  We have encountered excavators who choose not to dig in the winter because of wear-and-tear on their equipment. Others don’t feel like shoveling their equipment out of a snow bank and some excavator operators don’t like to work outdoors in the winter – I guess that’s their prerogative. I don’t like working in the cold either!

Transitioning from a fossil fuel heating system to a geothermal heating system is sometimes tricky. Sometimes we set up a temporary heat source if the transition is expected to take more than a day or two. I have encountered many homeowners who choose to tough it out by putting on some extra sweaters.

 

If you have your own questions about geothermal, please post them here, or send us an email. We’d be happy to answer them!